Nick Strokes is in the middle of fucking his stepsister Molly Little when Nick's girlfriend Penelope Kay walks in on them. Penelope storms out, and Molly suggests that Nick go after her. When Penelope sits down to hash things out, she clarified that she wanted Nick to talk about how he would fuck Molly to fulfill his stepfamily fantasy, not to actually do it.

Molly reaches out to run her hand down Penelope's thigh and suggests that they should indeed talk about it. Penelope offers that she thought it'd be hot to watch Nick and Molly make out, which Molly is happy to do. The girls keep on talking, with Molly eventually popping Nick's hardon out and inviting Penelope to play with it with her. Soon enough, the girls are making out in the build up to a threesome.

Molly finds herself in the middle with Nick sunk deep between her thighs and her mouth making love to Penelope's big boobies. Then Penelope takes a doggy style pussy pounding as she eats Molly out. Helping Molly climb into Nick's lap, Penelope masturbates while she watches and gets even hotter. When it's her turn to have Nick's stiffie again, she enjoys him pumping her full of the D as she lays on her back with Molly riding her tongue. The girls team up one last time to bring Nick off, then share his cum shot while agreeing they should do this again.