Maya Woulfe and Theodora Day are gossiping about girls at school when Theodora's stepbrother, Jay Romero, walks in on them. Theodora tries to involve Jay in the hot gos, but Jay just tells her that she makes everything about herself and stalks away. The next day, the girls are once again gossiping when Jay sees them. This time, he watches Maya compliment Theodora's tits while lifting Theodora's shirt for a better look. Running into the room, Jay tugs Theodora's shirt down to preserve his modesty.

The conversation turns to apple bottoms, but the girls keep making fun of their target for choosing the wrong outfit to compliment her ass. Jay suggests that maybe Theodora needs to get fucked before school to have a healthier release for her pent up energy than talking shit about others. Theodora hasn't had a boyfriend in over a month, but Maya points out that Jay looks to be up for the job. It takes some coaxing by both girls, but ultimately Maya helps Theodora get down on her hands and knees so Jay can shove his dick into his stepsister's pussy.

Now that Maya has helped get the stepsiblings started, she pulls her on own thong aside to masturbate as she watches. Theodora pulls Maya close so she can lap at her BFF's hairy muff as Jay keeps giving it to her. When it's Maya's turn to get her pussy pounded, she takes Jay's cock on her back as Theodora rides Maya's tongue in cowgirl. The girls swap out with Theodora on her back, enjoying Jay's fuck stick. When the girls arrange themselves into a 69 with Theodora on the bottom and Maya kneeling on top. That position allows Maya to diddle Theodora's snatch as Jay bangs her in doggy. He can also dip down to his stepsis's mouth. That's a prelude for the double BJ to come as the girls get on their knees and share Jay's cock until he delights them with a dual facial.