Alex Coal is into her stepbrother, Nathan Bronson, but she doesn't want to be too easy to get. She decides to send some mixed messages to mess with Nathan before she gets into his pants. She takes her time getting dressed, trying on first one outfit and then another as she admires herself in front of the mirror. On her second outfit, which features a top that easily pulls down to show off her boobs and a miniskirt that makes it clear she's not wearing any panties, she finally strikes gold. Alex is in the midst of taking some naughty selfies when she realizes that Nathan is watching her in secret, cock in hand.

Since Alex is already on her knees when she realizes that Nathan is behind her, she calls him into the room and taunts him about how cowardly he is to be watching in secret. She tells him that he'll never actually do the deed. Imagine Alex's surprise when Nathan actually does stick it in! When it initially happens, Alex is a bit taken aback. She decides she likes the way Nathan's cock feels filling her up, though, so she soon finds herself rocking back onto that hardon to encourage him to keep it up.

Taking a seat on the bed, Nathan pulls Alex on top of him so she can ride his stiffie. She doesn't hold back, bouncing away as she moans long and loud. Falling onto her back, Alex spreads herself wide open to urge Nathan to give it all to her. He delivers, diving deep and pounding away at Alex's tight glove. When he can't wait another moment to cum, Nathan makes sure to blow his load all over Alex's juicy snatch for a surprise creampie that leaves Alex upset enough to start calling for their parents in an attempt to get Nathan in trouble.