Jane Rogers and her friend Ashley Lane are making Valentine's Day cookies, complete with plenty of light flirting. When Jane's stepbrother, Tyler Nixon, joins them in the kitchen just to make fun of them, the girls kick him out of the kitchen and then decide to get back at him. They peel off their clothes until they're wearing just their aprons, then call Tyler back into the kitchen. They announce that Tyler can't have any cookies and he also can't have them.

Tyler isn't happy about the girls telling him what he can and can't do, so he steals a cookie and takes off. The girls manage to pull Tyler's pants down to slow him, but he gets away. Jane chases him to the couch, where she tackles him to get the cookie back. When Jane leans back, Tyler slips right into that juicy twat. Jane freaks a little bit, but she kind of likes how nice and thick Tyler's fuck stick is. Ashley likes seeing Jane and her stepbrother boning down so much that she insists on joining in. Soon Jane has hopped off the D so she can share a blowjob with Ashley.

Ashley gets to enjoy Tyler's hard dick in doggy as she and Jane make out. Eventually, Jane gets on her hands and knees in front of Ashley's face so her friend can eat her out. Then Jane rolls onto her back with Tyler pounding away at her cream filled fuck hole and Ashley riding her face. Ashley takes her turn on her back with Jane on top of her to present a double pussy stack for Tyler to keep on banging. When the girls are finally satisfied that Tyler has earned his cookie, they get on their bellies for one last mutual BJ until Tyler pops in their mouths to give them a treat of his own to share.