Jay Romero is on the floor looking through Christmas presents. His stepsister Molly Little and her friend Katie Kush find him and decide to mess with him. They tell him that there's a special gift for him but that it won't be under the tree until later. The girls have just finished putting Molly's ass in a box for Jay when he returns. He's super into his ass in a box!

Molly and Katie decide it'd be super hot for Jay to fuck Molly, so Katie encourages him to stick it in. Jay still thinks it's a fake booty and pussy as he does his stepsis in doggy. Totally turned on, Katie pulls out her tan lined titties to make out with Jay as he keeps Molly's party going. As soon as Molly is moaning from her orgasm, Katie pulls the blanket that's been covering her away to reveal to Jay that he's been doing his stepsister the whole time.

The gig is up, but the party isn't over. The girls drop to their knees to deliver a double BJ for Jay. Then Katie climbs on top to ride Jay's fuck stick in cowgirl. The girls have evened out their climaxes, so they lay down side by side in a pussy buffet for Jay to fuck. Molly begs Jay to cover her in cum, and he pulls out just in time to deliver on her wish. Katie sucks the tip and then licks some of the jizz from Molly's stomach before sharing a deep cummy kiss with her BFF.