Lacy Tate and Macy Meadows are on the search for Christmas presents, but they keep getting caught by Macy's stepbrother Jason. Jason catches them twice and tells the girls that if he finds them sneaking around a third time he's going to fuck them. They don't believe him, so they keep up the search and go to Jason's room, where he finds them again.

Lacy tells Jason that she dares Jason to do it and Macy doubles down by pulling down her shorts so Jay can stick it in. Lacy is loving it, rocking back and forth on the cock as Jason confesses they've done this before. He invites Lacy to join in, and Lacy doesn't have to be asked twice to get on her knees and fondle the balls. Then she strips down so Jason can have a pussy buffet to bang.

The girls flip onto their backs so that Josh can once again have his choice. Once Lacy has had her go on the D, Jason goes to banging Macy. Lacy takes that opportunity to ride Macy's tongue. The girls suck their goo from the cock and then Macy hops on in reverse cowgirl while eating Lacy out. The girls tag out, with Jason pulling out just in time to cum all over Macy's face to give the girls a Christmas present straight from his cock.