Chloe Temple wants her stepbrother, Jason, to take her to the fair instead of their adopted sister, Macy Meadows. The girls argue over which of them will get to be the one to go. Chloe thinks she has an edge up on Macy because she brings Jason some fruit, but Macy knows Jason is only interested in sex. She comes back in just her panties and a short shirt, offering to do a striptease. Chloe walks in on Macy before things can get too far, and insists that she can do it better.

The sisterly competition heats up as the girls decide the best way to determine the winner is to give Jason a blowjob. Chloe is the first to lean in and start sucking, but soon enough Macy gets her turn. When Jason doesn't seem to have made up his mind after his double BJ, the girls take even more proactive action. Leaning back into Chloe, Macy hops onto Jason's dick to ride him as Chloe masturbates and watches.

Chloe gets to enjoy Jason's cock between her thighs next when she rolls onto her back and takes him inside. After ensuring that Chloe's having a good time, Macy plants her pussy on her sister's mouth. Riding Chloe's face is a true treat for Macy, but so is getting on her hands and knees so she can be the middle of a sibling spit roast. Chloe takes her turn in the middle next, feasting on Macy's pussy juices as Jay bangs her. He finally reaches the end, pulling out to jizz on Chloe's ass and lower back. Macy follows instructions to lick Chloe clean and snowball Jason's cum with Chloe, and he finally agrees to bring both girls to the fair.