Natalia Queen knocks on her stepbrother Brad Sterling's door to tell him that they fucked a month ago when Brad was blackout drunk and that now she's pregnant. She suggests they tell Brad's mom, Claudia Monet, over breakfast. At the breakfast table, Natalia urges Brad to share her secret, but Brad refuses to be bullied. Claudia gets up to get a drink, which gives Natalia a chance to try to coax Brad into telling. He refuses, so Natalia pushes the subject by getting close to Brad and asking if Claudia has noticed how well they're getting along. Then Natalia drops some silverware and asks Brad to get it because she shouldn't in her condition. While Brad is under the table, Natalia makes sexy gestures at him. Brad excuses himself, unable to take it anymore.

A while later, Natalia calls her friend to tell her about how successful her prank was. Natalia's friend suggests that Natalia convince Brad they have to get married and that they should practice sleeping together. The friend wants embarrassing photos. Natalia agrees to try, so she gets into her pajamas and waits in Brad's bed to let him know. He tries to tell her to get out, but instead Natalia peels off her shirt and asks if he wants to see her like this every day. Then she lays back and shows him her meaty bare pussy. Natalia films as Brad strips but she drops her phone and goes to find it. That's when Brad slides into her tight pussy from behind.

Natalia wasn't expecting it to go this far, but once she gets a taste of Brad's dick she's super into it. She takes it doggy style, moaning her delight the whole time. Then she gets on her back and lifts her legs high in the air so Brad can pound her. After a quick BJ, Natalia climbs onto Brad's fuck stick and rides him as her tan lined titties bounce. He holds her in place with his big hands on her hips, pistoning in and out of her until he responds to her pleas to cum inside her. Satisfied with her creampie, Natalia admits the whole pregnancy was a big prank.