Bailey Brooke and her friend Lucie Cline are studying together when Bailey's stepbrother Logan Pierce asks them to help him study for his anatomy exam. Lucie offers to help out and goes up to his room. Logan tells Lucie that she needs to get naked, so she peels off her bra and flips up her miniskirt to let him take her panties off. Reaching out to slide his fingers up and down Lucie's slit, he gradually works his way to pressing two fingers into her tight twat. Lucie feels a twinge of guilt that she's playing around with her best friend's stepbrother, so she retreats to the living room.

Logan returns to the living room as well, this time returning to his bedroom with Bailey. He gets Bailey to strip down to just her socks so that he can inspect her pussy as well. When Bailey is open to Logan's advances, he pulls out his stiffie and sticks it into her from behind while claiming It's his thumb. His thrusts are just what Bailey needs to get off, which brings Logan right to the edge. Pulling out, he gives Bailey a facial of cum that is satisfying but still not enough.

They call Lucie back into the room and ask her to strip so that Logan can get a side by side comparison of their twats. Afterwards, they work in tandem to explore Logan's hardon with their warm mouths. It's not long before Logan has arranged Lucie on her hands and knees so that he can pound into her from behind as she muffles her cries of pleasure in Bailey's landing strip snatch.

When it's Bailey's turn to enjoy another pussy pounding, Lucie eagerly takes her opportunity to let her friend feast on her creamy fuck hole. As Bailey enjoys the deep pleasure of another climax, the girls rearrange themselves into a double pussy stack so that Logan can alternate between two delightful twats. As he reaches the end of his endurance, he shoots his load into Bailey's cum craving snatch in a hot creampie that drips onto Lucie's slit as they bask in the afterglow.