Summer Renee and Emma Rosie are besties, but they're pissed as hell that they both have the same costume for a Memorial Day party. The girls are fighting and tearing at each other's clothes when Emma's stepbrother Parker Ambrose comes in to see what the commotion is about. The girls insist that Parker decide who gets to be Lady America.

Parker asks the girls which one has better tits and then a better ass since superheroes obviously have great bodies. When Parker pops a boner, the girls argue over who can handle his dick better. They get on their knees and pop Parker's stiffie out so they can each blow him and suck his balls. Since Parker is still undecided, the girls know they have to take things further.

Pulling their tight superhero shorts down, they each lean over the bed so Parker can get his dick wet in each pussy. Then they roll over and play with each other's titties while Parker once again fucks first Emma and then Summer in that position. Emma climbs onto Parker's fuck stick for a stiffie ride, and then Summer gives him a go. Finally, the girls work together to help Parker pop. He claims he still can't tell them who won, but he had a good time.