Britt Blair and her friend Haley Spades are making Thanksgiving come to life with their baking. The two blondes watch the oven to see whether the pies they've made are done. While they're baking, Britt's stepbrother Tyler Cruise is busy making Thanksgiving crafts and getting plenty of pervy peeks up the girls' miniskirts. The girls begin to gossip about how pervy their stepfathers are. Haley makes a comment about how she would totally fuck Britt's stepfather, and Britt shoots back that Haley should go ahead because Britt already did. They call Britt's stepdad down to flash him and give him some pie. Tyler can't believe his ears!

Haley points out that Tyler heard and saw all of that, and Britt suggests maybe she should have some stepfamily fetish fulfilment. The girls flank Tyler and tease him about his crafts, giving Tyler the idea to slide his TP roll turkey onto his dick. That just causes the girls to tease him about what a little erection he has. Tyler comes back that it's not little at all. Britt teases Tyler by getting on her knees and flipping her miniskirt up since she knows he won't fuck her. She's giggling with Haley until Tyler slides it in and starts banging her in doggy. The sight of her friend getting fucked by her stepbrother is super hot, so Haley begins to masturbate as she watches.

Tyler isn't about to stop with just his stepsis. He Gets Haley on her back with her head cradled in Britt's lap and shows her firsthand that his dick is the perfect size. The girls are still wanting more, so Tyler has a seat as Haley helps him fuck Britt in reverse cowgirl. She gets to indulge in one last go with Tyler as she rides him in cowgirl to the sight of Britt masturbating. Then the girls get on their knees to suck Tyler off and rub his fuck stick until he rewards them with a double facial of cum.