Penelope Kay and her stepbrother Chase Arcangel have an unusual relationship that's about to get way weirder. Penelope has decided she wants to tap that, but she has a strange way of going about it. She waits until they're alone together putting away the dishes, and then turns away from Chase and starts talking to her imaginary real brother. Inviting her so-called real brother to her room, Penelope stalks out of the kitchen. She climbs into bed and goes on to show her imaginary brother her tits and then asks if he likes her panties. She's in the middle of rubbing her clit and finger banging her greedy twat for her imaginary brother when she decides to take things a step further.

Grabbing a stuffed bear, Penelope humps the toy while her boobs bounce from the motion. Things are just getting really good when Chase hears the commotion and peers in the door to see what's going on. He cannot figure out what is going on, so he enters the room and asks Penelope straight out. Penelope lets Chase know that she's playing with her "real" brother who is bigger and actually fucks her. Spreading her thighs, Penelope gives Chase a chance to be the better brother by touching her pussy. Chase isn't certain, but Penelope isn't taking no for an answer. She gets Chase's dick out of his pants and lays back so he can shove it in. Chase finds his stepsis nice and wet for his dick as he gives her what she's begging for.

Penelope repays Chase by pushing him onto the bed and blowing him, complete with a titty fuck. Then she climbs on top and sinks down onto his hardon for a full on stiffie ride. She sets a hot rhythm as she leans forward to let Chase squeeze those lovely titties. Eventually she leans further back so she can really go to work bouncing away. Getting on her hands and knees, Penelope moans as Chase comes back into her and gives her the rough pussy pounding she's been chasing. She winds up on her back, watching Chase as he fucks her to one last orgasm before pulling out and covering her from her trimmed twat to her face with his big load. Cum covered, Penelope lets Chase know she doesn't need her imaginary friend anymore because now she can fuck him whenever she wants.